Customers will spend more this holiday season, but inflation means their dollars won’t reach as far. The National Retail Federation expects holiday sales to rise grow by 4.2% to 1.013 trillion dollarswhile Adobe predicts online spending will increase 6.7% to 275.1 billion dollars. Inflation accounts for a significant portion of that growth, forcing shoppers to pay more for the same or smaller carts.
Discounts can make purchases seem like better deals, but they eat into margins and train customers to wait for the next promotion. Retailers have other ways to offer value – before purchase, at checkout and after delivery – without cutting prices.
Consider a medium-sized home and kitchen goods retailer with annual sales of approximately $200 million and a loyalty program that is little more than a mailing list of promotional codes. Here’s what you could do differently at each stage.
Don’t pay customers to wait to purchase
A decade of Black Friday conditioning has taught us that the list price is a sham. A full-price purchase is recorded as a loss, so the feeling of “getting less” kicks in before you’ve even added anything to your cart. The promotional calendar is where you can fix the problem or make it worse.
Our retailer’s calendar includes six holiday shipments between now and December 20th. Four with a percentage discount. Each teaches the customer to ignore the next full price email and wait for the next one. The calendar copies last year’s, which copied the year before. I’ve seen this at retailers with much more sophisticated stacks. Almost always, no one has any purpose for the mailings beyond generating revenue.
The alternative offers value through access, additions and service. The main price remains, but other elements change:
- The members take the first look. Early access for loyalty members replaces early rebates. Customers who sign up receive supplies before they run out, so the retailer doesn’t have to make a scheduling decision.
- Add instead of subtract. A package with a complementary item at the same main price feels like a gift. The retailer moves a slow SKU and protects the price of the fast one.
- Pay loyalty in service. Customers can redeem points for priority shipping, gift wrapping or a dedicated returns line. All of these are less expensive than the cash equivalent and customers will remember it for longer.
- Show inventory. Store-level product page stock tells the customer whether to drive. A retailer who hides such information to avoid disappointment will disappoint customers in the parking lot.
The retailer is trading two of its four percent-off mailings with a member first-time login campaign and a bundle announcement. The other two remain. Some discounts are fine. The goal is to stop making discounts the only thing in the email.
The calendar takes the customer to the shopping cart. What happens in the cart determines whether the purchase is completed.
10x your SEO with Semrush for business.
The most powerful SEO platform in the world, created specifically for businesses.
Request a demonstration
When purchasing, sell certainty rather than savings
When customers expect less for the same price, reducing risk is one of the most valuable things you can offer. Certainty has an operational cost, but it does not affect the margins of each order.
In Narvar’s 2026 Holiday Survey with eTail Insights, 70% of shoppers said an accurate delivery date at checkout is very important, ranking it as their top consideration. Reliable delivery dates also ranked within four points of price as a purchasing factor. Kenco’s peak season report found this out 82% of consumers rate return policies as important or very important. Customers want reassurance, but most retailers respond with a coupon.
The week before Thanksgiving, a competitor is offering a 20% discount on overlapping SKUs, including cookware, small appliances and gift sets. Instead of matching the discount, our retailer takes a different approach.
It offers a price match guarantee until December 24, refunding the difference if customers find the same item cheaper elsewhere. Few customers complain about it because most no longer check prices.
The retailer is also extending returns through January 31, generating a limited number of additional returns, mostly exchanges. Product pages show arrival dates tied to carrier cutoffs and store inventory in real time, so customers know when orders will arrive and what’s available locally.
Compare costs. A 20% discount reduces revenue on every order during the promotion, including purchases that would have been made anyway. Unlike blanket discounts, price match guarantees and extended returns incur additional costs mostly when customers use them. The retailer protects its margins by giving customers the confidence to buy now rather than wait for a better deal.
None of this works if marketing and operations aren’t planned together. The finance department must support the price match guarantee and the warehouse must deliver on the arrival dates. At most retailers, these teams meet in January to discuss who is responsible for the surge in returns. This year, meet in November.
Warranty received the order. The box has yet to arrive here.
After purchasing, make the box look like more than it costs
Between checkout and unboxing, customers decide whether they received “less.” It’s also the cheapest part of the season to improve, as most of this process already runs on autopilot.
The order confirmation appears to come from a database (and it is). The rewrite places the delivery date on the first line and includes a two-sentence explanation of the returns process. The shipping notification includes instructions for a late delivery before customers need to seek help.
Orders marked as gifts at checkout are shipped gift-wrapped by default (gift note in, invoice out). A week after delivery, another message asks nothing (no reviews, no survey) and provides a brief description of the product or the returns hotline.
I’ve seen retailers spend six figures on a Black Friday landing page and reuse last year’s shipping confirmation without even looking at it. That forwarding email is probably the most opened message all year. It’s also the one they pay the least attention to in design.
None of these changes affect the price. They determine whether customers see the purchase as a good decision or a necessary expense. The product in the package still costs what it costs. The retailer can still improve its surroundings.
Decide where to start
Forecasts project what customers will spend. If they think they got a good deal it stays open until the box is on the counter. Those three moments decide it.
Pull out your promotions calendar and count the emails that focus on a reduced price with nothing else interesting. Choose one certainty you can guarantee at checkout (return window, arrival date or price match) and highlight it on the product page. Open the shipping confirmation and read it like a customer would. All these fit in a week. None of them will show up on the income statement as markdowns.
People will probably spend more this season. It’s up to you to decide whether they will ultimately get less for their money.
